The last I left you we had just finished removing all of the caulk in our hall bathroom, scrubbing the left over grout and tile clean, and we were waiting for everything to dry completely before we applied the new caulk. After doing everything we could to remove the insidious mold that grew up under and around the old caulk, we were not about to take any chances caulking over damp crevices, and determined that we would wait at least a day to let everything dry before applying the new caulk. But not being ones to sit on our laurels watching grout dry, we decided to paint in the meantime.
We had already picked out a few front runners in the paint department that are consistent with the rest of the house’s updated color scheme, and had painted a few swatches on the walls. The front runners were Edgebomb Gray by Benjamin Moore, Moonshine by Benjamin Moore, and Paper White by Benjamin Moore.
As soon as it dried it became clear that Edgecomb Gray was not for us. It looked brown rather than greige in our windowless bathroom, and that was exactly what we were trying to get away from. So far this has been something of a theme in this under lit house of ours. The pretty, warm inviting greiges I see all over Pinterest look dirty and muddy when I get them on my walls. At least it makes picking a paint color a bit easier.
Moonshine and Paper White were the final contenders, and deciding between the two of them was not easy. Moonshine and Paper White are pretty similar. They are both light neutral to slightly cool grays that look a bit silvery or shimmery and change color slightly depending on the lighting. We liked them both, so we lived with the colors for a few days to see if one of them grew on us.
I waffled back and forth, leaning more toward one, then more toward the other. I looked at them during the day, at night, with the lights on, with the lights off, and stole quick glances at them every time I passed the door (as if I might catch the paint off guard while it was revealing its true nature). I was not really able to make up by mind until the shower curtain we ordered for the bathroom came in (I’m not showing it just yet – it’s a surprise, and it’s awesome). When we held the shower curtain up to our paint swatches the choice became clear. The Moonshine looked perfectly fine, but the Paper White really popped. We decided to go with Paper White, which is a bit lighter and brighter than Moonshine and looked great with our new shower curtain.
Money Saving Tip:
If you are planning a painting project and have an Ace Hardware nearby check to see if they are having one of their 2 for 1 paint sales before heading out to buy paint. A couple of times a year, Ace Hardware has a paint sale in which they sell 2 gallons of paint for the cost of one gallon. The brand and line of paint that is on sale generally changes each time, so if you are particular about the brand you paint with this may not be the sale for you, but if you are like me, and price trumps brand loyalty, it is a great way to get paint cheap – just make sure you buy enough to finish your project or are willing to pay full price if you run out.
We were lucky enough to buy the paint for this project during one of Ace Hardware’s 2 for 1 sales, so we got two gallons of BM Paper White color matched in Valspar Optimus for $40 . This should be enough to finish this project, and another we have planned (stayed tuned).
The ceiling paint is BM Simply White color matched to BEHR Premium Plus Ceiling Paint. It was leftover from painting the ceiling in our office and dining room. I love this color for a ceiling because it is definitely white, without being stark white. I feel like it makes the room feel a bit more welcoming than a true pure white.
We hadn't realized just how yellow the ceiling was until we started painting it. Just look at the before and after. It is like night and day! Next to the Simply White the old color looked like the teeth of a 3-pack-a-day smoker. The really troubling part is that we have no reason to suspect that the prior owner of 30+ years ever smoked in the house - we think they actually CHOOSE that color....
So here is what it looked like after 2 coats of Paper white on the walls and 2 coats of Simply White on the ceiling. The trim still needs to be painted and we need to do some touching up on both the walls and the ceiling. So far I am very happy with the paint color we chose, but there is a problem. The tile in the bathtub surround now looks pink!
Next time, figuring out what to do about the pink tile.